Politics : Red Dead Redemption is overrated and quite short.

For those of you who seem to think it's the best game ever you've obviously never played GUN. Most of the missions in RDD mainly consist of herding cattle and lassoing stallions. And you didn't even have a scalping option like GUN did.

Very ambitious game, through ,but too big to deliver and gets stale fast

Nobody here ever played GUN?

I have. It's decent, and much shorter than RDR.

I played GUN but my OCD got in the way of getting a quarter the way through.

---

Most of the missions in RDD mainly consist of herding cattle and lassoing stallions.

---

So you haven't played really played the game?

Always the artists.

I was referring to the beginning.

Yes I did play Gun on the X-box. It's the only western game I've played yet I love western films. It was good. Great voice cast too.

I enjoyed the game but It has been quite a while since I played it. Nothing exactly groundbreaking from what I remember but it was worth buying. I recall it being the wild wild west GTA. Didn't they have some zombie DLC also for it? I never played Gun but remember it but didn't buy it.

Quite short? You obviously failed all of the missions.

"Quite short? You obviously failed all of the missions."

Ok of all the Imdb insults that one makes no sense. It's implied that I aced all the missions in record time therefore it is short. If I had failed them like you say then it would have been longer because I would have taken longer to, Never mind.